Thursday, 5 July 2001

Fixed Term Workers - Correction

DELAY IN FIXED-TERM WORKERS REGULATIONS
------------------------------------------------

A correction to the previous message.

I stated that the Fixed Term Workers Directive had to be implemented by 10th July 1999. In fact, this date was a misprint in the English version of the Official Journal. The implementation date was corrected by a Corrigendum to the Directive, to 10th July 2001 with a 12-month extension if "special difficulties" exist.

So the government will not be out of time for implementing the Directive provided it can establish the "special difficulties".

(Thanks to the three people who corrected me on this!)

Tuesday, 3 July 2001

Seminar Notes - Remedies in Employment Disputes

SEMINAR NOTES - REMEDIES IN EMPLOYMENT DISPUTES
-------------------------------------------------

The notes from the 2 Gray's Inn Square seminar on Remedies in Employment Disputes (June 2001) are available free of charge to subscribers to this mailing list.

For a copy of the notes (Word format, 122K), please REPLY to this Email.

Thursday, 28 June 2001

Consultation Paper on Paid Holiday

The government has today published a consultation paper proposing changes to the Working Time Regulations 1998.

These proposals are as a result of Tuesday's decision of the ECJ in BECTU v UK (see bulletin 26.6.01), holding that the UK 13-week qualifying period for holiday pay is in breach of the Working Time Directive.

Curiously, the proposed amendments provide that in the first year of employment, holiday pay "shall accrue...at the rate of 1/12th for each month of employment". In other words, holiday entitlement will not start until the worker has worked for one month.

This appears to remain incompatible with the Working Time Directive, which provides for the right to paid holiday to begin accruing from the first day of employment.

The consultation paper can be downloaded from http://www.dti.gov.uk/er/work_time_regs/palconsult.pdf (Adobe Acrobat needed). The closing date for responses is 27th July 2001.

Wednesday, 27 June 2001

Lord Chancellor changes Discount Rate

NEWSFLASH - LORD CHANCELLOR CHANGES DISCOUNT RATE
-------------------------------------------

This afternoon, the Lord Chancellor has announced a reduction in the discount rate to 2.5%.

This will affect awards for long-term future loss of earnings in unfair dismissal and discrimination claims (the reduction from the long-standing 3.0% discount rate means that multipliers will be higher, and therefore awards will be higher).

The change will take effect from 28th June 2001.

Tuesday, 26 June 2001

13-week holiday rule unlawful

A number of people have been having problems receiving bulleins recently.
Until the problem is resolved, all messages are being sent in 'text' format.
Apologies for the unattractive appearance.
--------------------------

NEWSFLASH - BECTU v UK
------------------------

The ECJ has held, following the Advocate-General's opinion (see bulletin 8th February 2001), that the condition under the WORKING TIME REGULATIONS stating that the right to paid holiday does not accrue until workers have been employed for 13 weeks is unlawful.

This means that the UK will have to change the WORKING TIME REGULATIONS to remove the 13-week qualification period for paid holiday.

This decision will particularly affect people working in the media (who usually work on short-term contracts). It will also affect sectors such as cleaning, catering and security services, where short-term contracts abound.
Likewise, supply teachers (who often work for short periods) and temporary workers will benefit.

Monday, 25 June 2001

TUPE decision - ADI v Firm Security

Instructions on how to subscribe to this bulletin, and a DISCLAIMER, appear at the bottom of this Email.

On Friday (22nd June 2001), the Court of Appeal handed down its decision in ADI (UK) Ltd v Firm Security Group Ltd..

Facts
ADI provided security services at a shopping center. ADI terminated the contract, and the shopping centre initially stated it would take over the employment of the nine security officers. However, following a dispute over terms (prior to the 'transfer'), with the officers apparently indicating reluctance to be transferred, the shopping centre announced it would not be taking on any of the nine security officers.

The Employment Tribunal
The employment tribunal held (by a majority) that the provision of security services was not a discrete economic entitity and, in any event, there had been no transfer because neither assets nor staff were taken on by the shopping centre.

The Employment Appeal Tribunal
The EAT held (again, by a majority) that there had been a discrete economic entity, but that - due to the lack of transfer of assets and staff - there had been no transfer of the undertaking.

Issues for the Court of Appeal
The Court of Appeal (in line with precedent, by a majority!) allowed the transferor's appeal. It considered the following issues:
1. whether the tribunal was under a duty to consider whether the shopping centre had avoided taking staff on the avoid the effect of the TUPE regulations; and,
2. if so, what the effect of that was.

Issue 1: Was there a duty to investigate the motive behind not taking on any staff?
Both May and Dyson LJJ considered that there was an active duty on tribunals to investigate the motive behind not taking on any workers - provided the issue was raised by one of the parties. May LJ went further, and stated that there was not a positive burden of proof on the person arguing against the transfer to establish the reason for not taking on the workforce.

Issue 2: What is the effect of deliberately not taking on the workforce?
May and Dyson LJJ held that transferees could not escape the effect of the TUPE Regulations by the simple device of refusing to take on a workforce - the very mischief which the Regulations are designed to prevent. Thus, if it is decided that the transferee failed to take on the workforce so as to avoid there being a transfer, the tribunal should treat the case as if they had taken on all of the workforce. It must be noted that this point, whilst clearly agreed with by the majority of the Court of Appeal, was conceded by the transferee and was not fully argued.

In the minority, Simon Brown LJ held that the reason for not taking on the workforce was not relevant. The simple question was whether the workforce transferred (this being one of the many factors in deciding whether a TUPE-transfer had taken place). The reason was immaterial - either the workforce transferred (pointing to a TUPE-transfer), or it did not.

Comment
Because the point about the effect of a deliberate refusal to take on the workforce was conceded by the transferee, this is not as authoratitive a ruling as would otherwise be hoped for. Nevertheless, it follows the clear and useful dicta of the Court of Appeal in ECM v Cox. A purposive construction of the Acquired Rights Directive has always been adopted, and this approach is more consistent with a purposive construction.

To all people with TUPE headaches - take courage! May LJ stated that sections of the 1977 Directive have been "emasculated out of existence by purposive judicial interpretation", and that "the concept of transfer is now a judicially constructed fiction derived from the purpose of the Directive and the Regulations...". It is always heartening to know the Court of Appeal has trouble with TUPE concepts too!

Please note that I have prepared this note from a copy of the transcript which has been approved by the Court but which is subject to editorial corrections. Any quotations from the decision cannot be regarded as authoritative.

Friday, 22 June 2001

Government to promote Dispute Resolution

Instructions on how to subscribe to this bulletin, and a DISCLAIMER, appear at the bottom of this Email.

Determined to show it still has ideas after the general election, the government has this afternoon (Friday) announced a review of employment disputes to encourage dispute resolution.

Alan Johnson, employment relations minister, today announced that the government is concerned about the increasing number of tribunal claims - which do not appear to be related to the recently introduced causes of action (such as working time, minimum wage, parental leave etc.)

The government will therefore be issuing a consultation document shortly to consider alternative methods - other than litigation - of promoting good employment practice in the workplace. The review is not intended to amend employment rights, but will concentrate on the way in which those rights are exercised.

A factual background paper is available at http://www.dti.gov.uk/er/individual/dispute.pdf

Wednesday, 20 June 2001

The Queen's Speech - Legislation proposals

Employment Law (UK) List - http://www.danielbarnett.co.uk
Instructions on how to subscribe to this bulletin, and a DISCLAIMER, appear at the bottom of this Email.

The Queen's speech this morning included proposals for the following legislation:

• The Welfare Reform Bill, which will increase the rate of statutory maternity pay to £100pw from 2003, and increase the payment period from 18 to 26 weeks; and,

• The Female Representation Bill, which will allow political parties to "increase the representation of women in public life" via all women shortlists, should they so desire. Readers will recall that the 1997 Labour party women-only shortlist policy was declared contrary to the Sex Discrimination Act.

There was no mention of introducting anti-discimination legislation to comply with the EC Equal Treatment Framework Directive. Nor was there the much anticipated proposal for parternity pay. Still, there are four more sessions of parliament to go!!

Thursday, 14 June 2001

New Faces / EAT cases

Instructions on how to subscribe to this bulletin, and a DISCLAIMER, appear at the bottom of this Email.


CONTENTS

1. New Faces and Places
2. New EAT decisions

________________________________________

1. New Faces and Places

The government lineup for employment posts is as follows:

Work & Pension Secretary - Alastair Darling
Minister for Trade - Baroness Symons
Minister for Work - Nick Brown
Minister for Pensions - Ian McCartney
DTI Minister of State for Employment Relations and Regions - Alan Johnson

(I know it's not particularly interesting news, but occasionally it is useful to have a check list of who's who!)

________________________________________

2. New EAT Decisions

These cases are unreported (although some may be reported in due course). The transcripts were posted on the EAT website (http://wood.ccta.gov.uk/eat/eatjudgments.nsf) on 12th June 2001.


Jiad v BBC World Service [Hooper J., 5th June 2001]
An appeal by a litigant in person on grounds, in essence, of inadequate reasoning/perversity. The decision contains no points of law, but is of interest because of a costs order granted to the successful Respondent at the end of the appeal. This costs order was made despite stating that the appeal had been conducted properly by the Appellant, on the ground that the appeal was "of no merit and should never have been brought". Is this a sign of things to come under the new costs test (not yet in force)?



Asda Stores v Malyn [Lindsay J., 6th March 2001]
A long-standing ASDA employee allowed her son to use her 10% staff discount card. This was in breach of a very clear store policy, which the employee had signed and had drawn to her attention (in writing) on a number of occasions, stating that misuse of the card was gross misconduct. Despite the fact that the discount achieved was only £3, ASDA dismissed her because it said it had to be seen to apply the disciplinary rules consistently between all employees. The ET found the dismissal was unfair because, during the disciplinary process, the staff member has said she had not realised that gross misconduct would result in dismissal. The EAT overturned that decision. It laid down the following four rules (albeit tentatively, saying that it was overturning the decision on other grounds and the four principles did not form the ratio):

A dismissal will be fair, despite the employee's ignorance as to the actual consequences of an act, if:

1. there is a provision in the disciplinary code stating that a particular act or omission would amount to gross misconduct, with the possible sanction of dismissal (and it was reasonable in the industry to have that as an act of gross misconduct);
2. the employer takes reasonable steps, including asking the employee to sign it, to bring the disciplinary code to the attention of employees;
3. the employee knows he is doing wrong under the code; and,
4. the employee had access to the code.

Lana v Positive Action Training in Housing Ltd. [Mr Recorder Langstaff QC, 15th March 2001]
Ms Lana was a trainee quantity surveyor. She had a contract with Positive Action for Positive Action to find her a training contract / work placement for a year. Positive Action placed her with a firm (W) for training. After five months, she told W that she was pregnant, and W immediately cancelled the remainder of her placement. Positive Action subsequently terminated their contract on the basis that the placement had been terminated by W in circumstances beyond their control, and they had no alternative placements to offer. The tribunal found that this was a non-discriminatory reason for terminating the contract, and dismissed the claim under the Sex Discrimination Act. The EAT overturned this finding. It held that W was the agent of Positive Action for the purpose of providing training, and that Positive Action was accordingly vicariously liable for any discrimination by W under section 41 of the SDA 1975. Accordingly it remitted the case to a fresh tribunal.

Tuesday, 12 June 2001

Worker Consultation - EC Directive

Today's papers are flooded with the news that the EC has finally approved the proposed Directive for Informing and Consulting Employees in the European Community.

Assuming the Directive is formally passed and published (which is now fairly automatically - the approval being the controversial stage), the UK will have to implement the Directive within seven years (faster for employers with 150+ employees).

The legislation will require all employers with over 20 workers in a single workplace (or 50 workers throughout different workplaces) to inform and consult their employees on all crucial decisions, including:

• the reasonably foreseeable development of the undertaking's activities and its economic and financial situation (Art 4(1)(a));
• the situation, structure and reasonably foreseeable developments of employment within the undertaking (Art 4(1)(b)); and,
• most importantly - any decisions likely to lead to substantial changes in the work organisation or contractual relations (Art 4(1)(c)).

There are provisions enabling the domestic legislation to contain obligations of confidentiality, and there is an exception to the consultation requirement where "the nature of th[e] information or consultation is such that, according to objective criteria, it would seriously harm the functioning of the undertaking or would be prejudicial to it."

An important point on enforcement: the Directive states that domestic legislation must provide that, in cases of serious breach of consultation requirements relating to Art 4(1)(c) (ie the third bullet-point above), any business decisions taken - or dismissals made - will have no legal effect until the employer has fulfilled his consultation obligations (or, if no longer possible, made adequate redress).


Comment
This is an enormously controversial Directive, and the CBI's response has been quite scathing (see link to CBI below).

Prior to the election, the government published the Employee Consultation Rights Bill (see bulletin dated 3rd April 2001). It is insufficient to comply with the Directive, because it provides a penalty of up to four weeks' pay for breach of the obligations (rather than, as the Directive requries, stating that decisions to dismiss or vary contracts will - if the breach of the consultation obligations is serious - be of no effect). If the Bill is not made Directive-compliant, it will generate a significant (and expensive for the government) number of Francovich claims.

Wednesday, 23 May 2001

Remedies in Employment Disputes - Seminar Advertisement

ADVERTISEMENT

Remedies in Employment Disputes

a seminar by the 2 Gray's Inn Square Chambers Employment Group

Wednesday, 27th June 2001


TOPICS TO BE COVERED

• gathering evidence for the compensatory award, eg proving and disproving a failure to mitigate; the problem of older workers; employees who start a new business
• remedies in discrimination claims, including 'personal injury' damages in the tribunal, and remedies other than compensation
• settlement and compromise agreements, with special consideration of the tax implications of settlement
• TUPE update (written presentation only)


SPEAKERS

Milan Dulovic (1982)
Adrian Roberts (1988)
Daniel Barnett (1993)



ADMINISTRATIVE DETAILS

Date: Wednesday, 27th June 2001

Venue: The Morrison Hall, 1 Atkin Buildings, Gray's Inn, London

Time: 6.15pm registration (seminar commences 6.30pm; drinks and buffet 8.30pm)

Fees: First Delegate - £50+VAT; Subsequent Delegates - £45+VAT


For further information and a booking form, please contact Claire Halas on claire@2gis.co.uk

Tuesday, 22 May 2001

ACAS Arbitration Scheme

Employment Law (UK) List - http://www.danielbarnett.co.uk
Instructions on how to subscribe to this bulletin, and a DISCLAIMER, appear at the bottom of this Email.

The new ACAS Arbitration Scheme went 'live' yesterday (21st May 2001). It was initially delayed after fears that it would contravene the Human Rights Act 1998.

It is available for unfair dismissal claims only (ie not discrimination, working time, breach of contract etc.) and cannot be used where there are issues as to whether the employee was dismissed, or whether the employee has sufficient continuity of service to bring a claim. The parties must agree to adopt the arbitration route, and it is not appropriate for complicated questions of law (eg TUPE or EC issues). The hearings are private and are inquisitorial rather than adversarial in nature.

A short - and excellent - summary of the arbitration procedure can be found at http://www.oneclickhr.com/hrupdate .

The relevant statutory instrument, namely the ACAS Arbitration Scheme (England and Wales) Order 2001 (SI 2001/1185) can be found at http://www.legislation.hmso.gov.uk/si/si2001/20011185.htm.

ACAS have produced a guide to the arbitration scheme, at www.acas.org.uk/index-11.htm .

Wednesday, 9 May 2001

Jurisdiction for Ex-Employee to bring Sex Discrimination Claim

The Court of Appeal has held that claims cannot be brought under the Sex Discrimination Act 1975 by ex-employees, in respect of alleged acts of discrimination occurring after the dismissal.

The case is Christine Rhys-Harper v Relaxion Group plc (C of A, 3rd May 2001, reported at http://wood.ccta.gov.uk/courtser/judgements.nsf/6ff876ba66f8361a8025683c00411386/4abe4ebd835b7de280256a4700467803/$FILE/civil_rhys_harper.htm).

Facts
The Applicant was dismissed in October 1998. Shortly after dismissal, in November, she raised allegations of sexual harassment by her manager whilst she was employed. The Respondent held an investigation and rejected her complaint. She claimed that the failure to allow her complaint was a detriment for the purposes of the Sex Discrimination Act 1975.

Issue
Does section 6 of the Sex Discrimination Act 1975, which refers to a woman "employed by" a Respondent to claim that she was subjected to a detriment, allow an ex-employee to claim that she was subjected to a detriment?

Decision
No. The wording of section 6 is plain, and only allows claims brought by people who were employees at the date of the alleged discrimination. The ECJ in Coote v Granada Hospitality (where it was held that a reference provided after a dismissal was capable of founding a claim of victimisation under the Sex Discrimination Act) allowed very limited categories of claims. The Court of Appeal's reasoning in Post Office v Adekeye, where the Court held that ex-employees could not claim under the Race Relations Act 1976, should be followed when considering non-victimisation claims under the Sex Discrimination Act 1975.

Comment
Whilst a consistent approach towards ex-employees under the sex and race legislation is laudable, it is regrettable that Coote still complicates matters in claims of victimisation. Further, it is unfortunate that the sex and race legislation does not protect ex-employees in these situations - but that is a legislative matter and not one for the courts!


Friday, 6 April 2001

Discrimination against homosexuals - the MacDonald decision

CONTENTS

1. Discrimination against homosexuals - the MacDonald decision
2. Advertisement - job vacancy

________________________________________

1. Discrimination against Homoseuxals

The Scottish Court of Session has overturned the controversial decision of the EAT in Secretary of State v MacDonald.

The EAT decided as follows (from bulletin 2/10/2000):

The EAT has departed from previous authorities which hold that discrimination against homosexuals does not fall within the Sex Discrimination Act 1975.

It held that the word 'sex' in the Sex Discrimination Act 1975 is ambiguous - potentially including sexual orientation as well as gender. Despite the previous authorities to the contrary, it held that it is obliged to look at rights under the European Convention of Human Rights when, in two recent cases (Lustig-Prean and Salgueiro da Silva Mounta v Portugal), the European Court held that discrimination against homosexuals offended articles 8 (right to respect for privacy) and 14 (right not to be discriminated against when enjoying Convention rights) respectively.

Due to these new authorities, it was time to reconsider the traditional UK approach.

Accordingly, when considering a case of discrimination against a homosexual employee, the correct comparator under the Sex Discrimination Act 1975 is now a heterosexual (be it male or female) rather than a homosexual of the opposite gender.

The Court of Session has restored the orthodox approach in its decision of 1st June 2001, rejecting arguments that the Sex Discrimination Act 1975 can be used to bring claims based on sexual orientation.

All three judges considered that the word 'sex' in the Act meant 'gender', and there was nothing in the European Convention of Human Rights to indicate otherwise. The EAT had overstated the impact of the ECHR.

An important point was identifying the correct comparator. The majority thought that the correct compator with a gay man should be a lesbian. The dissenting judge thought that the comparator with a gay man should be a woman who was also sexually attracted to men. The majority, in considering that the correct comparator was a lesbian, held that Mr MacDonald had not been treated less favourably and therefore rejected his claim.

The decision can be downloaded from http://www.scotcourts.gov.uk/opinions/XA172_00.html

Comment
The Court of Session has departed from the EAT's decision, which appeared to be governed as much by laudable conceps of political correctness than strict application of legal principles. This, of course, is one of the arguments in favour of having two lay members sitting on the EAT (it is also one of the arguments against!)

Whilst this decision will be a blow for the rights of homosexuals in the workplace, the government is obliged to introduce legislation prohibiting discrimination on grounds of sexual orientation by December 2003 under the Equal Treatment Framework Directive.



________________________________________

2. Job Advertisement

THOMAS DUNTON
solicitors

Orpington, Kent

are looking for a

LITIGATOR

for their forward looking Dispute Resolution Group

Minimum one year's experience
• expanding practice
• varied civil caseload
• private and publically funded work
CV to Thomas Dunton solicitors, 217/219 High Street, Orpington, Kent BR9 0NZ
Telephone 01689 822554
Email office_manager@thomasdunton.co.uk



Tuesday, 3 April 2001

Employee Consultation Rights Bill

The Employee Consultation Rights Bill has been published. It has little prospect of being enacted due to the imminent general election (unless re-adopted in the next session of parliament).

It provides an obligation for all employers with more than 50 employees to inform and consult workers (and their representatives) on "large business issues", including:
• developments relating to employment within the undertaking, including foreseeable redundancies; and,
• proposed decisions of the employer which are likely to cause significant changes to the organisation of work or to contracts of employment.
The obligation to inform extends to providing "information on all relevant facts".

An obligation of confidence is imposed on the workforce representatives, who are prohibited from disclosing information to others. The Bill provides that breach of the confidentiality requirement is "actionable at law". If the employer says information is confidential (and thus cannot be disclosed by the workforce representatives), the representatives can apply to the CAC for a declaration as to whether the information is truly confidential.

The penalty for failing to inform and consult, or for providing inadequate or inaccurate information, is that each affected employee shall be paid a 'protective award' of four weeks' gross pay on application to an employment tribunal.

The Bill can be found at http://www.parliament.the-stationery-office.co.uk/pa/cm200001/cmbills/027/2001027.htm

Monday, 2 April 2001

New Acquired Rights Directive - 2nd message

Further to my bulletin of 23rd March 2001 (reproduced below), the Acquired Rights Directive 2001 appeared in the Official Journal on 22nd March 2001. It therefore comes into force on 11th April 2001. Thanks to all those who Emailed me with the date.

Henry Scrope, who is responsible for the excellent www.emplaw.co.uk site, has put together a table comparing the old and new Acquired Rights Directives. It can be accessed via his commentary page on http://www.emplaw.co.uk/cgi-bin/frame/load/data/11001802.htm . Although access to the site normally costs £5+VAT for a 24-hour password, he is offering 24-hour passwords free of charge. Readers can obtain a free trial password by Emailing disclaw@community.co.uk .

Wednesday, 28 March 2001

New Employment Tribunal Rules of Procedure and ACAS Arbitration Scheme

The DTI has, today, laid the Employment Tribunals (Consitution and Rules of Procedure) Regulations 2001 (SI 2001/1171) before parliament. They are due to come into force on 18th April 2001.

The main changes from the existing 1993 Regulations are as follows:

• new reg. 10 inserts an overriding objective to enable tribunals to deal with cases 'justly'.
• consolidation/simplification of rules relating to directions regarding evidence.
• costs rules amended to make it clear that the unreasonable conduct of a party's representative may be taken into account when deciding whether to order costs.
• costs rules also amended to introduce a DUTY to consider costs in certain circumstances, including where proceedings had no reasonable prospect of succes
• costs rules also amended to increase assessment limit from £500 to £10,000
• the word 'frivolous' in the tribunal's power to strike out 'frivolous' etc. cases has been replaced with 'misconceived' - this would appear a wider power to strike out
NB the Regulations have not yet been posted on the HMSO website, but no doubt will appear there soon.

In addition, the DTI has given a firm(er) timetable for introduction of the much-heralded ACAS arbitration scheme for unfair dismissal claims. Full guidance will be available in April, and the scheme is expected to commence in late May 2001.

Saturday, 24 March 2001

Race Discrimination - Anya v Oxford University - C of A

On Friday 23rd March, the Court of Appeal handed down its decision in Anya v Oxford University (http://www.courtservice.gov.uk/judgments/judg_home.htm).

NOTE: the EAT decision in this case is summarised in my bulletin of 16th May 2000


FACTS
Dr Anya (who is a black Nigerian) had, with one other candidate (who was white) been shortlisted for a senior academic post. One of three interviewing panel members knew Dr Anya extremely well, and had formed a view that he was not suitable for the post. He told one, but not the other, member of the panel of his views before the interview took place. In the event, the panel unanimously offered the post to the other candidate. Dr Anya claimed racial discrimination.


ISSUE
It was common ground that Dr Anya had been treated less favourably (having not been offered the post). The question was: was it legitimtate to infer that this was on grounds of race?


THE EMPLOYMENT TRIBUNAL
The employment tribunal recited a number of incidents which Dr Anya complained of which pre-dated the interview. It then held that despite the interviewers having been caught making inconsistent statements, they were fundamentally truthful and honest witnesses. Accordingly it accepted that the other candidate was the better person for the job and that there was no racial inference to be drawn. Having found that there was no racial inference to be drawn, it thought it unnecessary to consider the other allegations (which drifted back over some lengthy period of time).

The Employment Appeal Tribunal noted that no evidence of overt discrimination had ever been identified. It held that it was unncessary for the tribunal to make express findings of fact on each of the ancillary, historical matters, because the tribunal was entitled to take an "overview" and it was quite apparent that, even if findings of fact were made in Dr Anya's favour, they would not amount to "compelling grounds" to find that the non-appointment to the academic post was 'proabably' on grounds of race.


THE COURT OF APPEAL
The Court of Appeal has allowed Dr Anya's appeal, overturning the employment tribunal and the EAT.

The Court stated that inferences of racial motive could only be drawn from detailed primary findings of fact. A single allegation of discrimination could not be viewed in isolation, but the history of dealings between the parties should be taken into account in order to determine whether it is appropriate to draw an inference of racial motive in respect of the principal allegation.

The employment tribunal had erred in deciding that the appointment of the other candidate was not racially motivated, and then considering it unnecessary to deal with all the other, historical, matters that had been raised. Instead, it should have made primary findings of fact on all those other matters and then, looking at the relationship between Dr Anya and the interviewers as a whole, decided whether racial motive could be inferred. By focussing on the actual interview itself (and the circumstances immediately surrounding it), the tribunal failed to make sufficient findings of fact as to all the cirumstances to enable it to be in a position to draw inferences.

Accordingly, "in spite of the daunting consequences of doing so", the case was remitted to the employment tribunal.


COMMENT
Whilst undoubtedly correct from the purist viewpoint, this approach will result in the legthening of many of the already complex and time-consuming race cases before tribunals. It seems now that a tribunal will be making an error of law if it does not permit an Applicant, whether represented or not, to trawl with tedious particularity through every real and perceived grudge that has arisen during his/her employment history.

Members of the Employment Lawyers' Association will have seen a letter by HHJ John Prophet, President of Employment Tribunals, to the Editor in this month's ELA Briefing. In it, he describes how tribunals are succeeding with ensuring speedier justice whilst continuing to safeguarde the interests of justice. This decision of the Court of Appeal seems to promote the latter, but without engaging in the modern approach of balancing it with the former.

Friday, 23 March 2001

New Acquired Rights Directive

On 12th March 2001, the EC Council adopted the new Acquired Rights Directive 2001. This repeals and replaces the Acquired Rights Directive 1977 (which is the source of the TUPE regulations).

The preable states it is a codifying Directive and, indeed, on reading it I have been unable to find any material differences between it and the 1977 Directive (as amended).

Nevertheless, for those who want to see it, it can be downloaded from http://europa.eu.int/eur-lex/en/dat/2001/l_082/l_08220010322en00160020.pdf

The implementation date is the 20th day following its publication in the Official Journal of the European Communities - which could be very soon, or quite some time away!

Thursday, 22 March 2001

Damages for Manner of Dismissal - House of Lords

A busy day for the House of Lords, who have handed down five judgments - three of which are employment related.

First, in Johnson v Unisys Ltd. (http://www.parliament.the-stationery-office.co.uk/pa/ld200001/ldjudgmt/jd010322/johnso-1.htm), the House of Lords upheld the rule in Addis v London Gramaphone Co Ltd. [1909] AC 488 that damages are not recoverable at common law for the manner of dismissal. The Lords differed in their reasoning but, unanimously, held that such damages could not be recovered.

It therefore remains the case that damages for wrongful dismissal are limited to the net monies that would have been earned during the notice period.


FACTS
Mr Johnson is now 52 years old. He worked for over 20 years for a computer software company. Over the years he suffered from work-related stress, of which the employers were aware. In January 1994, general allegations were made of misconduct and, without any specific allegations being put or any fair hearing held, he was summarily dismissed.

As a result, he developed a severe psychiatric illness involving in-patient treatment, hypnotherapy for 2 years, intensive psychotherapy, anti-depressant drugs etc., and his health continued to remain severely affected. He still remains unemployed, and his loss of earnings was pleaded in excess of £400,000.

He brought a claim for unfair dismissal, but was awarded only £11,698 due to the (then) statutory maximum.

Accordingly he issued a claim in the county court for (as later amended) breach of the implied term of trust and confidence, in that the manner of dismissal should not be such so as to damage/destroy the relationship between the parties. The County Court Judge, upheld by the Court of Appeal, struck out the claim. Mr Johnson appealed to the House of Lords. NOTE that the claim was solely for financial losses, not for general damages for the psychiatric illness.


DECISION
A number of issues arose:

(i) Was Addis v Gramaphone Co Ltd truly authority for the proposition that damages are irrecoverable for manner of dismissal?
4 of the 5 Lords said that it was authority, albeit that it was a difficult decision to understand. In a minority, Lord Steyn held that the headnote was wrong and that, properly constructed, Addis did not give rise to any such rule of law.


(ii) Should Addis be overruled?
The House of Lords unanimously agreed that social conditions since Addis in 1909 were wholly different. "It is no longer right to equate a contract of employment with commercial contracts (Lord Steyn)". "...over the last 30 years or so, the nature of the contract of employment has been transformed. It has been recognised that a person's employment is usually one of the most important things in his or her life...The law has changed to recognise this social reality (Lord Hoffman)". It was therefore open, if appropriate, to depart from the rule in Addis.

However, the policy arguments divided the House of Lords (even if the end result was the same). The two main arguments were:

Policy Argument 1: Can the implied term of mutual trust and confidence 'trump' an express term entitling an employer to dismiss on notice?
Lord Steyn thought the two terms could co-exist. Even if employment could be terminated on notice, it did not abrogate the employer from the co-existent implied term not to exercise the right to dismiss in a way which damaged the employee's prospects of future employment. He described the term of trust and confidence as "an overreaching obligation implied by law as an incident of the contract of employment."

Three of the others (Lords Bingham, Hoffman and Millett) considered that the terms could not co-exist. The express term trumps the implied term. The term of trust and confidence was only relevant to an ongoing employment relationship, and ceased to have effect in connection with the termination of that relationship.

Lord Nicholls did not consider this point.


Policy Argument 2: Does the Unfair Dismissal legislation provide an adequate remedy?
On this point the House of Lords was divided 4:1.

In the majority, Lords Bingham, Nicholls, Hoffman and Millett held that parliament had intended all issues relating to losses flowing from the unreasonableness of the manner of a dismissal to be dealt with by the unfair dismissal legislation. Parliament having intervened in this way, and provided a effective remedy to resolve such disputes, it was inappropriate for the civil courts to introduce a right to bring claims for losses flowing from dismissal in the civil courts - particularly when such claims would bypass the time limits and compensation limits for unfair dismissal. Malik v BCCI was not an exception - in Malik the breaches of contract by the bank occurred before the dismissal.

Lord Steyn, in the minority, considered that the unfair dismissal legislation would still be perfectly workable if the House of Lords departed from Addis. The fact that parliament legislated because it thought the courts lacked the right at common law to provide an effective remedy did not preclude the courts from deciding that, in fact, they do have the right at common law to provide a remedy.

For the above reasons, by a 4:1 majority the House of Lords held that the rule in Addis should stand.

Lord Steyn, in the minority, held that Addis should be overruled. However, he held that Mr Johnson's appeal must fail in any event because Mr Johnson had no realistic prospect of establishing causation on the facts of the case. His losses, on the facts, were too remote and there was no reasonable prospect of success.


My summary of today's two other employment decisions by the House of Lords will follow>