Wednesday, 20 December 2000

Consultation Paper on Young Workers

The partial opt-outs from the Young Workers Directive, adopted by the UK in 1998, ended in June 2000. The government is now consulting on how to implement the remaining provisions of the Directive into UK law.

Younh workers are defined as being over the minimum school leaving age, but under 18.

The three areas which are likely to be introduced (by amendment to the Working Time Regulations) are:

• limiting young workers' working hours to 8 per day and 40 per week. There is no provision for averaging working hours over a period of time. However, the 8 / 40 hour maxima may be excluded when there are objective grounds

• prohibiting young workers from working between 12 midnight and 4am. Exemptions exist for the armed forces or where there are objective grounds. Amongst other things, this is likely to prevent young people from working in nightclubs or as DJs at discos.

• prohibiting young workers from working between EITHER 10pm and 6am OR 11pm and 7am - but there is greater scope for derogation.

The consultation period over the scope of any amendments to the Working Time Regulations closes on 30th March 2001.

More detail can be found on the DTI website at http://www.dti.gov.uk/er/individual/ywconsult.htm

Wednesday, 13 December 2000

Service Ban on Homosexuals to be removed

According to an article in today's Times reporting an interview with Geof Hoon, the Defence Secretary, the armed services are to lift the ban on homosexuals serving next month.

A new code of conduct will be published in January concerning behaviour standards irrespective of sexual orientation. This will state that behaviour alone will determine whether the sexuality of a man or woman will consitute grounds for dismissal. A known homosexual who conforms to standards of military discipline will be treated no differently from a heterosexual colleague.

This follows the ruling by the European Court of Human Rights on 27th September 1999 in the cases of Jeanette Smith, Graeme Grady, Duncan Lustig-Prean and John Beckett (see bulletin of that date) which held that the U.K. was in breach of article 8 of the ECHR (right to respect for family and private life).

Although this Code is welcome, the armed services continue to disciminate on grounds of gender (eg Sirdar v UK in which, last month, the European Court of Human Rights held that the refusal of the Royal Marines to employe a female chef was not incompatible with the Convention). No doubt this will be discussed at a government conference, being held tomorrow in Birmingham, on racial and sexual equality in the armed forces. However, Geoff Hoon is reported in The Times as indicating that "there might still be good reasons for doubting the wisdom of giving women front line combat roles.". He is quoted as saying "I'll look at it, but there is no presumption in favour of it."

Plus ca change...


PS - Just a reminder - the Maternity and Parental Leave etc Regulations 1999 come into force on Wednesday - see bulletins dated 5th November and 25th October 1999

PPS - Please note that the advertisements which have appeared recently at the footer of some of these messages are imposed by the ListBot server (which I use for distributing these bulletins) and do not form part of these bulletins. I am arranging to have them removed, and they should not be appearing after Christmas.

Thursday, 7 December 2000

Working Parents: Government reveals Green Paper

The government has, today, issued its proposals for Working Parents, in a document entitled "Work and Parents: Competitiveness and Choice".

A consultation paper will be issued within the next 3 weeks, to enable people to state which of the Government's proposals are preferred. The proposals include:

  • two weeks paid paternity leave for fathers;
  • lengthening the period maternity leave is paid to six months;
  • extending unpaid maternity leave so a woman could stay at home for a year;
  • sharing any increase on existing unpaid maternity leave equally between the mother and father;
  • increasing the flat rate of maternity pay - currently £60.20 per week;
  • allowing an adoptive parent - either male or female - to take paid leave similar to maternity leave when adopting a child; and
  • increasing the amount of parental leave available to the parents ofdisabled children, currently 13 weeks.

The Green Paper also includes several options on flexible working either through legislation or incentives to business including:
  • Giving mothers who return early from maternity leave the right to work reduced hours for the rest of that time;
  • giving fathers the right to work reduced hours until the end of maternity leave;
  • allowing both parents the right to opt to work reduced hours for as long as they wish, when the maternity leave period ends;
  • giving all employers the right to refuse a request to work reduced hours if it would harm the business; and
  • exempting employers with a certain number of employees from granting any requests to work reduced hours, except for mothers for a short time;
  • a kitemark that organisations committed to an appropriate code might display with a mechanism for taking the kitemark away if opportunities for flexible working are removed. This would be backed up with a challenge fund for small businesses to meet some of the up front costs of providing more flexible working opportunities.

Given the overwhelming improbability of legislation before the general election, the Green Paper may be regarded by many as ammunition for campagining rather than an indication of impending change.

Further details can be found at http://www.dti.gov.uk/er/review.htm

Tuesday, 5 December 2000

Equal Treatment Framework Directive

Published at last! The English version of the Equal Treatment Framework Directive 2000 is now available, and is attached to this Email (128K - sorry about the length!) in .pdf format. You need Adobe Acrobat to read it.

The main points are:

1) The UK must introduce legislation prohibiting discrimination in employment on grounds of religion or belief, disability, age or sexual orientation.

2) The religion, belief and sexual orientation legislation must be in force by 2nd December 2003. The disability and age legislation must be in force by 2nd December 2006.

3) Positive action is expressly permitted.

4) There is a defence of 'genuine occupational requirement' for all types of discrimination.

5) There are specific defences for age discrimination, provided it can be shown to satisfy a legitimate employment policy. These defences include:
• remuneration conditions for young or older people;
• fixing of minimum conditions of age, professional experience or seniority for access to employment;
• fixing of minimum age requirements for training.
6) It is specifically stated that a mandatory retirement age is NOT to be regarded as age discrimination.

7) The burden of proof shifts to the employer once the employee has shown a prima facie case of less favourable treatment.

8) The Directive does not apply to the armed forces, but there are no other excluded sectors.

Interesting times ahead....

Equal Treatment Framework Directive

Employment Law (UK) List - http://www.danielbarnett.co.uk
I've had two Emails telling me that the Directive, attached to my last bulletin, was corrupted.

If anyone can't access it, it can be downloaded from:

http://europa.eu.int/eur-lex/en/dat/2000/l_303/l_30320001202en00160022.pdf

Monday, 4 December 2000

New Guide on Parental Leave

A guide to maternity and parental leave rights, which apparently includes a section on time off for emergencies, has been launched today by the DfEE. The guide is aimed primarily at small businesses.

According to the DfEE press release, the guide can be found at http://www.employmentservice.gov.uk/ . However, it is not up there yet!

Friday, 1 December 2000

TUC Survey on Safety at Work

CONTENTS

1. TUC Survey on Safety at Work 2000 - stress at work major factor

2. New EAT decision

________________________________________

1. TUC Survey on Safety at Work 2000

This is an annual survey published by the TUC, after interviewing 9,000 safety reps. The reps identified the following as the major hazards at work:

(1) stress or overwork (identified by 66% of safety reps)
(2) back strain (44%)
(3) RSI (41%)
(4) Display Screen Equipment (36%)
(5) working alone (32%)


Of the reps who identified stress as a major hazard at work, they cited the following as the main causes:

(1) workload (cited by 74% of reps identifying stress as a major hazard)
(2) cuts in staff (53%)
(3) change at work (44%)
(4) long hours (39%)
(5) shift work (30%)
(6) bullying (30%)

________________________________________

2. New EAT Decisions

These cases are unreported (although some may be reported in due course). All transcripts can be found at http://wood.ccta.gov.uk/eat/eatjudgments.nsf.


Davis v Tibbett & Britten Group [29.2.2000, HHJ Collins]
An 9-month old decision, only just posted to the EAT website yesterday! The EAT says it is not necessary for an employer to obtain medical evidence, when dismissing for persistent absence, where the employee suffers from a series of transient illnesses rather than one long, ongoing, illness

Wednesday, 29 November 2000

Age Discrimination / New EAT decisions

CONTENTS
1. Age Discrimination - Awards of Excellence for Age Awareness
2. New EAT decisions

________________________________________

1. Age Discrimination - Awards of Excellence for Age Awareness

Margaret Hodge, Employment and Equal Opportunities Minister, has today awarded eight recruitment consultancies the first Age Diversity in Recruitment Awards of Excellence. This is part of the government's effort to ensure that business considers candidates on the basis of their skills and experience, and not their age.

Readers will recall that the government issued a Code of Practice on Age Diversity in Employment on 16th June 1999. This was in lieu of its pre-election promise to introduce age discrimination legislation (Hansard, 9th Feb 1996). However, the Code is voluntary only and appears to have had little effect. A survey by the Employers’ Forum on Age revealed that 3 in 10 employers had never heard of the Code, less than 1 in 10 intended to make any changes to the way they recruit and train, and 68% said that a voluntary code will make no difference to the way they run their business. According to a report in The Times (15th June 2000), the Prime Minister’s advisory unit on older people recommended that the Code of Practice be replaced with a statutory code.

The proposed EC Employment Framework Directive is due to be formally agreed within the next day or so, which will require member states to introduce age discrimination legislation by 2006.

________________________________________

2. New EAT Decisions

These cases are unreported (although some may be reported in due course). All transcripts can be found at http://wood.ccta.gov.uk/eat/eatjudgments.nsf.


Adegbite v Commissioners of Inland Revenue [14.11.2000, Bell J.]
The Applicant appealed on the basis that, in a long(ish) race discrimination case, her comparatively inexperienced trade union representative was against a very experienced employment Counsel and was thus at a disadvantage, leading to a possible perception of bias. The EAT rejected this argument, holding that the parties chose their own representatives and the informality of tribunal hearings did not lend themselves to such arguments. The EAT also endorsed the Chairman's power when limiting the length of a representative's cross-examination.


Chelsea Village Management Ltd -v- Omar Ali [1.11.2000, HHJ Wilson]
The Applicant was awarded approx. £22,000 in a race discrimination case. Although the appeal was allowed on the merits on the grounds of insufficient reasoning, the EAT specifically stated that the failure to set out the factors for, and the different heads of, the award rendered the decision on quantum flawed.


Professional Development & Selection Ltd. -v- Wahab [26.10.2000, Mr Commissioner Howell]
The employer attended a full hearing without any witnesses, having been erroneously informed by his solicitors that it was a directions hearing only and that he needed neither witnesses nor legal representation. The chairman, who was sitting alone, rejected an application for an adjournment. The EAT remitted the substantive case to a fresh tribunal on the basis that the chairman had not properly considered whether it was appropriate for him to hear the case alone. It did not comment on whether the refusal of the adjournment was a wrongful exercise of discretion.

Monday, 27 November 2000

ET costs increase to £10,000

As leaked to this morning's Daily Telegraph(!), at midday the DTI formally announced the proposed new changes to Employment Tribunal powers.

The main changes, which are expected to come into force in early Spring 2001, are:

• an increase in the costs limit for frivolous, vexatious etc. behaviour from £500 to £10,000. Although the press release does not make this clear, presumably tribunals will retain the power to send costs to the county court to be assessed. A new power will be introduced to allow tribunals to take into account the unreasonable behaviour of representatives;

• a new power for tribunals to strike-out cases which have no real prospect of success;

• an increase in the deposit for weak cases (after a PHR) from £150 to £500;

• measures to increase tribunal case management.

Draft Regulations will be published early in the New Year.

New ACAS Arbitration Scheme

The DTI announced today that ACAS is introducing a new arbitration scheme, for unfair dismissal claims only.

It will provide a cheap(!) and informal alternative to tribunal hearings. One advantage is that the arbitration is confidential, ie not in the public doman like tribunal hearings.

ACAS will be producing formal guidance on the scheme in due course.

Friday, 24 November 2000

Guide for Employees taking Industrial Action

The DTI has today published a guide for employees / trade union members who are considering taking industrial action.

Entitled 'Industrial Action and the Law (PL869 REV4), it can be downloaded from http://www.dti.gov.uk/er/union/employees-pl869.htm

Thursday, 23 November 2000

Legal Aid Available for ETs in Scotland



According to an article in The Scotsman (20.11.00), the Scottish executive has made legal aid available for bringing claims in employment tribunals. This is regarded as a 'pre-emptive strike' in view of the current claims being brought in Scotland under Article 6 of the ECHR for failing to provide legal aid (see bulletin 23/5/00)

It is expected that legal aid will be available for ETs in Scotland (not England or Wales) from 15th January 2001.

Friday, 17 November 2000

TUC calls for Email Code at Work

The TUC and the Industrial Society are, at today's (Friday's) TUC Conference on Human Rights, calling on employers to sit down with unions and draw up Codes of Practice for their staff on Email usage. They have jointly produced a set of guidelines of do's and don'ts regarding the sending and receiving of emails.

The guidelines suggest that any code of practice should set out to encourage responsible behaviour, good management practice and safeguard worker privacy. Policies should:

• warn users that emails may be electronically scanned for obscene, indecent, racist or illegal remarks

• allow for the occasional and reasonable personal use of email, as long as this does not interfere with an employee's work

• give assurances that emails between union reps and members will not be monitored or read by managers

• remind employees that their emails may be checked by others at work if they are unexpectedly absent or have gone on leave without leaving forwarding arrangements.

TUC General Secretary John Monks said: "Good relationships at work are based on trust. The recent regulations have left many employees worried that managers might be snooping on their personal emails. And employers fear that if they open any email containing private information, they could be breaching the Human Rights Act. But instead of reacting by banning the personal use of email at work, it makes more sense for employers to consult with their workforce and draw up guidance which protects and reassures everyone."

Industrial Society Chief Executive Will Hutton said: "The explosion of new technologies in the workplace has risks as well as rewards. Employers are increasingly aware of `cyberliability' and email abuse and are using more covert and intrusive methods of surveillance. While employers have legitimate interests to protect, over zealous monitoring can undermine employees' dignity and autonomy within the workplace. It is essential that employers develop sensible solutions with their employees to promote good practice in this area, based around openness, consent and consultation with their employees."

The TUC guidelines say that employers need to protect themselves and their staff from abusive or obscene email, but that this should not be at the expense of employee privacy. Good employers with email policies will usually seek the consent of an employee before monitoring takes place, and only act after a complaint has been received.

Thursday, 16 November 2000

Responses to Tribunal Review consultation

Yesterday the Lord Chancellor's Department published the results of the responses to the Tribunal Review consultation. Sir Andrew Leggatt, heading the Review team (see bulletin 18/5/00), is due to report to the Lord Chancellor by April 2001.

The responses can be seen at www.tribunals-review.org.uk

Almost 300 responses were received. The review dealt with all tribunals - thus covered (eg) educational needs tribunals, mental health tribunals, the Child Support Agency, immigration tribunals, rent review tribunal as well as employment tribunals.

I summarise some of the important responses (so far as they apply to ETs):


Jurisdiction
Most of the jurisdiction comments related specifically to employment tribunals. Many responses thought that ETs should:
• become the forum for litigation instituted by the employer, not just the employee;
• hear all cases involving contractual jurisdiction, whether or not the employee remained in employment and including restrictive covenants;
• therefore have authority to grant injunctive relief;
• be enabled to make recommendations to the employer to improve work practices (as well as awarding compensation) after a successful unfair dismissal claim;
• have an increased limit on claims (particularly basic and compensatory awards) or an unlimited jurisdiction;
• be the starting point for ALL discrimination claims (including discrimination re goods and services), although there should be the possibility of transfer to the county court;
• take the work of the reserve forces appeal tribunals.

There was some comment about the overlap between DDA cases in the ETs, and PI actions in the county court, but no firm recommendations were made.


Costs
A (small) minority of those responding said that tribunals should have a general power to award costs. Employment tribunals were specifically mentioned as being a venue where the limited costs powers were not effectively used in practice. In particular, it was suggested that the late withdrawal of an employment application should ordinarily attract cost sanctions.

It was noted that employment tribunals were amongst the most expensive of all tribunals, with costs for employers sometimes running into tens of thousands of pounds.


Procedure
For employment tribunals, formal procedures were appropriate. Oral hearings, rather than paper submissions, were desirable.

The significant majority wished to retain employment tribunals as separate bodies (even if in favour of merging other types of tribunals).


Impartiality
A significant minority thought that tribunals (generally - not limited to ETs) were not, or not perceived as, independent. The main problems revolved around appointment procedures and the inherent lack of independence in the wing members (again, not specifically ETs).

Friday, 20 October 2000

Various matters

CONTENTS

1. Whistleblowing case
2. Anti-Discrimination Directive
3. Advertisement - CPD service

________________________________________

1. Whistleblowing Case

John Bowers QC of Littleton Chambers has sent me a transcript of an employment tribunal decision relating to an important point of principle in whistleblowing cases.

The tribunal held that the Public Interest (Disclosure) Act 1998 protects employees who make protected disclosures prior to the date the Act came into force. On the facts, the employee made a protected disclosure about four months before the Act came into force. A year later (after the Act had come into force), the employer relocated him to a different department (which was said to be a detriment).

The tribunal held that it had jurisdiction under PIDA 1998 to consider the employee's complaint, despite the protected disclosure occurring prior to the Act coming into force.

Edgar v Meteorological Office, Employment Tribunal (London central) chaired by Mrs JR Hill on 5th October 2000, sent to the parties on 11th October 2000.

________________________________________

2. Anti-Discrimination Directive

Many readers will have read in the news that the EC has now approved the long-awaited Employment Framework Directive. According to press reports, it requires all member states (including the UK) to introduce legislation:

• prohibiting discrimination against workers on grounds of religion and sexual orientation by 2003; and,

• prohibiting discrimination against workers on grounds of disability and age by 2006. Note that although the Disability Discrimination Act 1995 may comply with the requirements of the Directive, rumour has it that there is no 'small employer' exemption within the Directive - thus the DDA will have to be amended to apply to all employers, not just those with over 15 employees.

I have not yet seen a copy of the Directive. Once I have a copy, it will be made available via this mailing list.


________________________________________

3. Advertisement

REMINDER

The current session of the Employment Law (UK) mail list CPD Scheme closes on 1st November 2000, when the answers to this quarter's questions will be published.


It is now possible to obtain CPD hours for receiving these bulletins.


How does the Scheme work?

By answering multiple choice questions based on the employment law bulletins sent out in the previous 3 months, you can obtain 2 CPD hours each quarter.

The questions (and an archive of the last 3 months' bulletins) are available at www.cpdpoints.co.uk

The number of CPD hours awarded depends on the number of correct answers to the multiple choice questions, as follows:
5 or more correct (out of 12) - 1 CPD hour
7 or more correct (out of 12) - 1.5 CPD hours
9 or more correct (out of 12) - 2 CPDhours

How much does it cost?

There is no charge for attempting the questions.

Your score (and number of CPD hours to which that entitles you) will be sent to you by Email. You may then, if you wish, purchase the CPD hours for a fixed fee of £100+VAT.



How do I answer the questions?

The questions, and an answer form, are available online at www.cpdpoints.co.uk . All the answers can be found in the Employment Law (UK) bulletins as sent over the last few months. If you have not retained them(!), copies can be found on www.cpdpoints.co.uk .

For those who do not have access to the internet, a list of the questions will be distributed by Email next week.

The answers will be published on 1st November 2000. New sets of questions, based on the preceding 3 months' bulletins and entitling you to obtain yet more CPD hours, will be produced every quarter.



www.cpdpoints.co.uk and the CPD assessment scheme are adminstered by Employment Law Services Limited. Employment Law Services Limited is accredited by the Law Society as an authorised provider of CPD courses.

Tuesday, 17 October 2000

Phone Tapping

Rumour has it that my previous bulletin demonstrated quite how complicated employment law has become - being a mass of unreadable garbage!

What it should have contained was the text of the Telecommunications (Lawful Business Practice)(Interception of Communications) Regulations 2000 (mentioned in my bulletin dated 5th October). It has now been published and is reproduced with the permission of Her Majesty's Stationery Office. Please find the Regulations attached in HTML format.

Thursday, 5 October 2000

New Regulations on Email and Telephone Monitoring

The Telecommunications (Lawful Business Practice)(Interception of Communications) Regulations 2000 have been published under the Regulation of Investigatory Powers Act 2000.

Apart from having an impressive title, the Regualations set out the circumstances in which an employer can record or monitor employees' communications (such as Email or telephones) without the consent of either the employee or the other party to the communication.

These circumstances are very wide, and they include:

  • for recording evidence of business transactions;
  • ensuring compliance with regulatory or self-regulatory guidelines;
  • maintaining the effective operation of the employer's systems (eg preventing viruses);
  • monitoring standards of training and service;
  • preventing or detecting criminal activity;
  • preventing the unauthorised use of the computer/telephone system - ie ensuring the employee does not breach the company's Email or telephone policies.

It is necessary under the Regulations for employers to take reasonable steps to inform employees that their communications might be intercepted. This reinforces the need for all employers to introduce an Email / internet policy for their workers.

The Regulations come into force on 24th October 2000.

www.incomesdata.co.uk) for notifying me of these Regulations>

________________________________________

ADVERTISEMENT

New CPD Scheme launched for this list


It is now possible to obtain CPD hours for receiving these bulletins.


How does the Scheme work?

By answering multiple choice questions based on the employment law bulletins sent out in the previous 3 months, you can obtain 2 CPD hours each quarter.

The questions (and an archive of the last 3 months' bulletins) are available at www.cpdpoints.co.uk

The number of CPD hours awarded depends on the number of correct answers to the multiple choice questions, as follows:
5 or more correct (out of 12) - 1 CPD hour
7 or more correct (out of 12) - 1.5 CPD hours
9 or more correct (out of 12) - 2 CPDhours

How much does it cost?

There is no charge for attempting the questions.

Your score (and number of CPD hours to which that entitles you) will be sent to you by Email. You may then, if you wish, purchase the CPD hours for a fixed fee of £100+VAT.



How do I answer the questions?

The questions, and an answer form, are available online at www.cpdpoints.co.uk . All the answers can be found in the Employment Law (UK) bulletins as sent over the last few months. If you have not retained them(!), copies can be found on www.cpdpoints.co.uk .

For those who do not have access to the internet, a list of the questions will be distributed by Email next week.

The answers will be published on 1st November 2000. New sets of questions, based on the preceding 3 months' bulletins and entitling you to obtain yet more CPD hours, will be produced every quarter.


www.cpdpoints.co.uk and the CPD assessment scheme are adminstered by Employment Law Services Limited. Employment Law Services Limited is accredited by the Law Society as an authorised provider of CPD courses.

Tuesday, 3 October 2000

Company Directors and Doctors' Working Hours

CONTENTS

1. Minimum wage and company directors
2. ECJ Decision - Doctors' maximum working hours

________________________________________

1. Minimum Wage and Company Directors

An Inland Revenue agreed guidance note on the impact of the minimum wage on company directors has been issued by the Tax Faculty of the Institute of Chartered Accountants.

The note is particularly useful for its guidance on when a director is also an employee.

It can be downloaded from http://www.taxfac.co.uk/facultypublications/documents/11-520-1.doc

________________________________________

2. ECJ Decision - Doctors' maximum working hours
The ECJ has, this morning, handed down its decision in Sindicator de Medicos de Asistencia Publica v Spain.

It held that Spanish primary care doctors are subject to the maximum 48-hour week.

The important sections of the judgment, which is available at http://www.curia.eu.int/jurisp/cgi-bin/gettext.pl?lang=en&num=79998996C19980303&doc=T&ouvert=T&seance=ARRET&where=() ,are to hold/confirm that:

  • trainee doctors are not subject to the 48-hour week, they being a specific exemption from the Working Time Directive;
  • doctors who are 'on-call' at a health centre are counted as working, for the purpose of the Working Time Directive;
  • doctors who are 'on-call' away from a health centre (ie at home) are not counted as working, for the purpose of the Working Time Directive;
  • doctors who are 'on-call' at night are not rendered 'night workers' simply by reason of the Directive.
________________________________________

ADVERTISEMENT

New CPD Scheme launched for this list


It is now possible to obtain CPD hours for receiving these bulletins.


How does the Scheme work?

By answering multiple choice questions based on the employment law bulletins sent out in the previous 3 months, you can obtain 2 CPD hours each quarter.

The questions (and an archive of the last 3 months' bulletins) are available at www.cpdpoints.co.uk

The number of CPD hours awarded depends on the number of correct answers to the multiple choice questions, as follows:
5 or more correct (out of 12) - 1 CPD hour
7 or more correct (out of 12) - 1.5 CPD hours
9 or more correct (out of 12) - 2 CPDhours

How much does it cost?

There is no charge for attempting the questions.

Your score (and number of CPD hours to which that entitles you) will be sent to you by Email. You may then, if you wish, purchase the CPD hours for a fixed fee of £100+VAT.



How do I answer the questions?

The questions, and an answer form, are available online at www.cpdpoints.co.uk . All the answers can be found in the Employment Law (UK) bulletins as sent over the last few months. If you have not retained them(!), copies can be found on www.cpdpoints.co.uk .

For those who do not have access to the internet, a list of the questions will be distributed by Email next week.

The answers will be published on 1st November 2000. New sets of questions, based on the preceding 3 months' bulletins and entitling you to obtain yet more CPD hours, will be produced every quarter.


www.cpdpoints.co.uk and the CPD assessment scheme are adminstered by Employment Law Services Limited. Employment Law Services Limited is accredited by the Law Society as an authorised provider of CPD courses.

Monday, 2 October 2000

Human Rights Act [autoreply 021000]

Just in case anyone has missed it, the Human Rights Act 1998 comes into force today.

Copies are available of my article 'Employment Law and Human Rights', which was published in ELA Briefing in March 2000, on my website . Alternatively, to obtain a copy in Word format (56K) by Email, just reply to this Email (ensuring that the phrase 'autoreply 021000' appears in the subject line) and it will be sent automatically.

Discrimination against Gays now Unlawful

The transcript of MacDonald v Ministry of Defence (EAT, 17th September 2000) has just been published.

The EAT has departed from previous authorities which hold that discrimination against homosexuals does not fall within the Sex Discrimination Act 1975.

It held that the word 'sex' in the Sex Discrimination Act 1975 is ambiguous - potentially including sexual orientation as well as gender. Despite the previous authorities to the contrary, it held that it is obliged to look at rights under the European Convention of Human Rights when, in two recent cases (Lustig-Prean and Salgueiro da Silva Mounta v Portugal), the European Court held that discrimination against homosexuals offended articles 8 (right to respect for privacy) and 14 (right not to be discriminated against when enjoying Convention rights) respectively.

Due to these new authorities, it was time to reconsider the traditional UK approach.

Accordingly, when considering a case of discrimination against a homosexual employee, the correct comparator under the Sex Discrimination Act 1975 is now a heterosexual (be it male or female) rather than a homosexual of the opposite gender.

The transcript can be downloaded from:
http://wood.ccta.gov.uk/eat/eatjudgments.nsf/faf4a44f36aa53fc80256794004040c2/fcac7ff40afaec3c8025696c0039e3c0?OpenDocument

Note: if the link does not work (it may be too long for some browsers), try http://wood.ccta.gov.uk/eat/eatjudgments.nsf