Wednesday, 21 March 2012

London (East) Tribunal

For those practitioners with cases due to be heard at London (East) Tribunal in the next couple of weeks, be aware you may experience difficulties.

The tribunal is sending out letters cancelling hearings on the basis that it has "reached the full extent of the budget allocation for this financial year and, as a result, there is no remaining judicial resource available to hear your case."

I have made enquiries as to whether this affects all cases being heard before the end of the year, or just some of them. A listing officer at London (East) told me the position was unclear (and I was unable to speak with the Head of Listing), and he said the 'end of the year' referred to 5th April 2012.

The Tribunals Service Press Office told me that the position was "under review" and it was "possible additional funds would be allocated".

It may be that the lack of funds means London (East) cannot use fee-paid (part-time) judges, but the salaried (full-time) judges are still sitting. London (East) is generally quite reliant on fee-paid judges. Whilst this situation is obviously undesirable, congratulations to London (East) for grappling with the problem and notifying parties. It would be far worse to turn up on the day to find there was no judge available.

Dual Contract Arrangements

HMRC has published guidance on Dual Contract Arrangements.

Dual Contract Arrangements are most commonly seen where a foreign domiciled worker works both inside and outside the UK. S/he may claim to have two employment contracts, usually carefully drafted, and the bulk of income may be attributed to the contract which appears not to be subject to UK PAYE taxation. HMRC is sometimes suspicious of such arrangements and will investigate them.


The new
guidance sets out the evidence which HMRC expects an employer to keep, and explains how it approaches the question of whether work in the UK is 'merely incidental' to employment outside the UK.

Thursday, 15 March 2012

Marital Discrimination

[Thanks to Ed McFarlane of Deminos HR for preparing this case summary]

Is it unlawful discrimination on the grounds of marital status if a spouse is dismissed (or suffers some other detriment) on the grounds of being married to a particular person?


No, says the EAT (Underhill P) in
Hawkins v Atex Group, unless the ground for the less favourable treatment is specifically marriage, as opposed to a close relationship which takes the form of marriage.

The Claimant was employed for less than a year by a company her husband managed when a policy prohibiting employment of close relatives was implemented, leading to her (and her daughter's) dismissal. An employment tribunal struck out her claim of unlawful discrimination on the grounds of marital status, and her appeal failed.


The EAT observed that in this case, there was no general rule or criterion applied by the employer about married women, the decision to dismiss applied to the Claimant and her daughter, and the Respondent was not motivated, in whole or in part, by the fact that the Claimant was married to her husband.


The EAT considered and departed from the recent case of
Dunn v Institute of Cemetery and Crematorium Management under which detriments arising from being married to a particular person, not only being married, could found a marital status discrimination complaint, and doubted some of the reasoning in Dunn. So there is a conflict of authority on this point. The EAT noted that it had been referred to an authority not cited in Dunn.

Call for Evidence on Dismissal Rules

The government has launched a Call for Evidence as to whether dismissal rules and the Acas Code of Practice are too complex or misunderstood. It has also launched the call for evidence, as leaked last week, on whether to introduce a system of no-fault compensated dismissals for microbusinesses (with under 10 employees).

The link on the BIS website to the Call for Evidence is currently broken, but you can read the Press Release.

Tuesday, 6 March 2012

TUPE: Substantial Change in Working Conditions

[Thanks to Dr John McMullen of Wrigleys Solicitors LLP for preparing this case summary]

Can a change of location on a TUPE transfer give rise to a claim for constructive, automatically unfair, dismissal?


Yes, says the EAT (Langstaff P) in
Abellio London v CentreWest London Buses.

The 5 claimants in this case worked as bus drivers for CentreWest, which ran the 414 bus route operated from its Westbourne Park depot. This location suited the employees' family circumstances, and where they lived. The route was transferred to Abellio. It intended to operate the route from its own depot in Battersea. It was accepted by the parties that this was a service provision change, and therefore a relevant transfer, under Reg 3(1)(b) of TUPE.


The claimants all had objections to the new location. It affected their travel and domestic arrangements. The new location would mean between 1 and 2 hours extra travelling per day. They resigned. It was held by the employment tribunal that there had been a substantial change to the employees' working conditions to their material detriment under Reg 4(9) of TUPE. The move was additionally a repudiatory breach of contract (in that a mobility clause in the employment contract did not extend to the Battersea location). Therefore the employees were also constructively dismissed for the purposes of Reg 4(11) of TUPE. It followed that the dismissals were automatically unfair, being by reason of the transfer.


The EAT agreed, citing with approval the EAT decision on the same point in Tapere v South London and Maudsley NHS Trust [2009] IRLR 972.


Redundancy: Pool of One

[Thanks to Nicholas Hill of Outer Temple Chambers for preparing this case summary]

When should an employment tribunal interfere with the pool for selection chosen by the Employer?


Rarely, says the EAT (HHJ McMullen QC) in
Halpin v Sandpiper Books.

Sandpiper Brooks employed Mr Halpin in its London office as an Administrator/Analyst. Mr Halpin moved to work in a sales role in China. In due course the Company decided to outsource the sales work and Mr Halpin was put at risk of redundancy. There was extensive consultation and he was offered (but refused) alternative employment back in the UK.


Mr Halpin was dismissed by reason of redundancy and brought a claim for unfair dismissal. The claim was dismissed. The tribunal concluded that Mr Halpin had been fairly selected for redundancy "in so far as he was in a pool of one given his unique position dealing solely with sales and based in China".


The EAT upheld the tribunal's approach. The decision by the Respondent to limit the pool to a pool of one was open to it; such a decision cannot be easily overturned. "Selection only operates, when fairness is concerned, where there is a number of similarly qualified possible targets for redundancy" (paragraph 16) there was no other "similarly qualified possible targets". The decision as to the pool is one for management (Fulcrum Pharma v Bonassera [2010] UKEAT/0198/10/DM). In the circumstances the decision was one that was reasonably open to the Employer.